I like both, but when I read New Moon, my obsession with Edward ended when I fell for Jacob. Even though he isn't real.
I think Bella should be with Jacob, because Edward abandoned Bella and left her broken hearted. Though I still LOVE Edward, I think it would be best for her to be with Jacob.
So I vote for Team Bella, because she should be the one to chose who to be with. If she picks Jacob, good for her, but if she picks Edward, I think she should become a Vampire. No matter his theories of death.